A law professor says a Liberal government bill that would make it easier for police and spies to navigate the online world could be found unconstitutional due to a provision on retaining metadata.
The “lawful access” bill would require service providers to keep metadata — digital traces of a communication, but not the email or text itself — for up to six months.
The government agreed to shorten the period, which was originally up to one year, after expressions of concern.
On Monday, University of Ottawa law professor Michael Geist told a Senate committee studying the bill the provision remains “constitutionally vulnerable with little evidence of its necessity.”
Geist said metadata may not include the content of a message, but it tells a story: who we contact, when, where and from what device.
The government says the bill will ensure law enforcement has the legal tools to prevent, investigate and respond to modern crime and protect Canadians in a manner consistent with the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Opponents argue the legislation unnecessarily expands the powers of police and intelligence agencies, endangering the privacy of Canadians, flouting the Charter and placing unreasonable demands on companies.
Geist said police seeking access to metadata can use existing Criminal Code provisions allowing targeted preservation and production orders tied to a specific investigation with judicial oversight.
He said the bill’s metadata regime should be removed. Failing that, requiring metadata retention for up to 30 days would address the concerns about meeting immediate investigative needs prior to obtaining a preservation order, Geist said.
Tamir Israel, director of the privacy, surveillance and technology program at the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, also called on Monday for removal of the data retention regime, or at least limiting it to apply only to data already under the control of telecommunication providers.
The bill would require electronic service providers to develop and maintain the technical capabilities necessary to enable police and the Canadian Security Intelligence Service to effectively obtain communications and information for investigations.
Critics of the legislation say it could allow the government to force companies to break encryption by inserting backdoors into their products.
Israel told the senators the bill “effectively grants the government a blank cheque to impose its evolving surveillance objectives onto electronic service providers in secret.”
Earlier this month, Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree told the Senate committee the bill “is not about weakening privacy protections. It is not about surveillance. It is not about creating backdoors to Canadians’ private communications.”
In addition to the shorter metadata retention period, a House of Commons committee adopted a safeguard clarifying that electronic service providers would not be required to comply with an order if it would introduce a systemic vulnerability in their services or prevent them from fixing one.
Robyn Greene, director of privacy and public policy at Meta Platforms, the company behind Facebook, told the senators Monday the company provides end-to-end encrypted services to help Canadians protect their most sensitive information.
“It is not technically feasible to give law enforcement backdoor access to encrypted data without introducing a vulnerability that malicious actors will exploit,” Greene said.
“Simply stated, forcing service providers like Meta to break, weaken, circumvent or undermine encryption would significantly harm Canadians’ privacy, cybersecurity, economic and national security.”
Greene said the government’s well-intentioned amendments do not achieve their goal.
“We also remain concerned the technical order authorities could force providers to install government or third-party spyware onto our systems.”
In addition, Greene said, the metadata retention obligations “treat all Canadians as potential criminal suspects.”
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 16, 2026.
By Jim Bronskill | Copyright 2026, The Canadian Press. All rights reserved.

