More than three decades after Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman were murdered, O.J. Simpson’s former friend Kato Kaelin is revisiting five unusual things the former NFL star did on the night of the killings.
Kaelin, who was living on Simpson’s property at the time, says several seemingly ordinary interactions have taken on a disturbing significance in hindsight.
In a recent interview with Decider, Kaelin reflected on his memories of June 12, 1994, when Brown Simpson and Goldman were fatally stabbed outside her Los Angeles home. He also discussed the events in Peacock’s documentary OJ’s Accomplice, which explores theories that Simpson may have received assistance from others.
“I question myself all the time,” Kaelin said while recalling his interactions with Simpson that evening.
The first detail that stood out to Kaelin was Simpson unexpectedly coming to the door of his bungalow. According to the former houseguest, Simpson had never previously visited his guesthouse in that manner.
The second unusual moment involved a request for cash. Kaelin remembered Simpson asking him whether he could break a $100 bill. Although the request might not have seemed particularly remarkable at the time, it became another detail he would revisit when reflecting on that night.
The third incident happened when Simpson announced that he was going to get something to eat. Kaelin asked whether he could accompany him, but Simpson reportedly paused for an unusually long time before agreeing.
Looking back, Kaelin believes his unexpected decision to join Simpson may have disrupted the former football star’s plans. He suggested that he had “ruined his timeline.”
The fourth moment came during their drive to McDonald’s, which Kaelin recalled taking place between approximately 9 and 9:45 p.m. He remembered Simpson being unusually withdrawn throughout the journey.
“Definitely he was in this mood. He was not very talkative in the car…he was silent,” Kaelin told Decider.
He added, “I can’t get into someone’s mind, but there was something 100 percent on his mind.”
The fifth detail emerged after they returned from the food run. Kaelin expected Simpson to join him for a meal, but instead, the former football star simply stood there.
Kaelin also offered a troubling assessment of his former friend’s personality, describing Simpson as “charismatic” and recalling how much he enjoyed being admired. He added, “I really think he was a sociopath.”
His opinion about the murders remains unequivocal.
“I think OJ is 100 percent guilty,” Kaelin said.
Simpson was acquitted of the murders in October 1995. However, a civil jury found him liable for the deaths of Brown Simpson and Goldman in 1997.
OJ’s Accomplice also revisits allegations involving Simpson’s associates, including A.C. Cowlings and Charlie Ehrlich. However, Kaelin remains unconvinced by the alternative theories, telling Decider that he believes “OJ acted alone.”
Simpson died in April 2024 at the age of 76.

