A new study co-authored by Dr. Emma Duerden says children who spent more time with screens each day had poorer language skills.monkeybusinessimages/Getty Images
On Nov. 18, Dr. Emma Duerden and generations reporter Ann Hui answered reader questions on the effects of screen time on young children and what parents and educators should know.
Dr. Duerden co-authored a new study which found that the children who spent more time with screens each day (including televisions, tablets and iPhones) had reduced volumes in the area of the brain associated with language development, as well as poorer language skills.
Growing evidence shows potential harmful effects of screens on young children
Readers asked about the impact of screen time, navigating how to regulate it and what has worked for parents. Here are some highlights from the Q&A.
Screen time with kids
Guidelines recommend one hour of screen time per day for children aged two to four, but many families are exceeding these recommendations.Yuri Kageyama/The Associated Press
Dr. Duerden, you said in the article that this is a “public health issue.” Could you expand on that and explain what that means we should do about it?
Dr. Emma Duerden: Screens have become excessively integrated into young children’s lives – despite there being a growing body of research showing associations between excessive screen use and poorer language, attention and other developmental skills.
We already have guidelines recommending one hour per day for children aged two to four. But many families are exceeding these recommendations.
The average parent is unlikely able to control all screen use even for their young children. That’s why I think we also need broader public health recommendations for screen use in public spaces, child care centres, schools, community centres and health care settings.
It’s about creating environments that provide the best possible opportunities for healthy brain development.
Screens impact time playing pretend. What are the consequences of the lack of pretend play?
Dr. Duerden: I think we’ve forgotten that children don’t need to be entertained all the time. Being bored occasionally and having play time, inventing games and being creative are important parts of growing up.
Through play, children develop language, problem-solving skills, imagination, social skills and the ability to regulate their emotions and attention. When screens disrupt these experiences, children may miss important opportunities to develop these skills.
I’m curious about how different content affects children. Is it the technology or the content that is deleterious to young brains?
Dr. Duerden: Not all screen time is equal! Video calls are excluded from screen time even for young children. Watching high-quality programming designed for children or slower-paced videos that children can understand are more recommended.
Dr. Duerden, how did you conduct your study and why was this topic important for you?
Dr. Duerden: We followed two-year-olds until they were three and assessed their language abilities, had them undergo MRI scans to examine the structure of their brains and asked parents about screen time at ages two and three.
This topic was important to us, as previous research demonstrated associations between high levels of screen time in little kids and speech-language delays.
By conducting brain imaging studies with toddlers, we had the opportunity to see if there was associations between screen exposure, language skills, the structure of language regions in the brain and later screen use at three years of age.
Correlation is not causation. Maybe the kids with lower language skills are more drawn to screen time?
Dr. Duerden: That’s a good point. Our study wasn’t designed to establish causation. However, we did follow children over time, which allowed us to better understand these relationships rather than looking at just one point in time.
We found that children who spent more time on screens at age two tended to have poorer language skills, including few spoken words and smaller vocabularies. We also found that children with poorer language skills and smaller volumes in a brain region involved in language at age two tended to spend more time on screens at age three.
While we can’t establish causation from our study, our findings add to a substantial body of research, including large population studies and systematic reviews, showing associations between greater screen exposure in young children and poorer language development.
We know that young children learn language primarily through interactions with other people. One concern is that excessive screen time may disrupt opportunities for conversation, play and the back-and-forth interactions that are so important for language development.
Are televisions really the same as a phone or a tablet? It’s a lot slower paced, with fewer things demanding your immediate attention.
Dr. Duerden: TV shows typically undergo a higher level of editorial content review in comparison to videos/shorts/shows on YouTube or other similar platforms. For young children, slower-paced media that has educational programming can even offer some benefits. Moreover, you are more likely to want to watch with them.
Setting an example
More screens at home often means fewer back-and-forth exchanges between parents and children, Dr. Duerden says.Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press
Don’t parents know the harms of screen time by now? Why are they still letting young kids use these harmful devices?
Hui: Just chiming in as a parent, to say that even with awareness, it’s not always so simple.
Whether it’s birthday parties at movie theatres, or TVs that are at restaurants or in doctor’s offices or even malls, screens are everywhere. I only recently learned that my kid’s school was showing TV and movies in the classroom during lunch hour – not as an educational tool, but as a way of managing kids with fewer lunchroom monitors. All of this sneaky screen time often happens even without parents knowing.
Dr. Duerden: Awareness varies a lot among parents. Some studies report around 60 to 76 per cent awareness about guidelines and adverse effects – but parents may not even know what the recommendations are in terms of daily hourly limits. However, parents who know what the guidelines recommend about screen time are more likely to reduce screen time for their children.
In the end, this speaks to the broader public health issue that screen use poses.
Do we need to fundamentally change the way parents look at young children? Parents feel the need to constantly entertain their child, and default to screens when other resources are depleted.
Hui: This is such an interesting question that I think gets at a much larger conversation around parenting expectations. It’s well-documented that the amount of time that parents today spend with their children – on everything from physical care and homework to participating in leisure activities – has increased exponentially over the years.
The average mother in Canada today spends 7.5 hours per day parenting (it’s just under five hours for average fathers). This is at least double the amount of time that parents spent with their kids 50 years ago, according to many studies.
Part of it is likely because we’re having fewer children in this country. But I’m sure a part of it also is just that expectations have changed – around what it means to be a parent, what parenting involves, and how to be a “good” parent.
Most of these parents are also addicted to their screens and can’t put their own phones down. How can we expect them to regulate screen time for the children?
Dr. Duerden: Lots of adults struggle with constant connectedness and high levels of screen use. Even a term for this is increasingly being used – “technoference” – in clinical and research spaces!
Research has shown more screens at home often means less adult words spoken, fewer sounds and words spoken by children, and fewer back-and-forth exchanges between parents and children.
In terms of regulating screen use habits by parents, there likely isn’t a one-size-fits-all remedy because of family or work commitments.
However some routines can be easy to implement, particularly for families with young children who have regular bed times and nap times. Avoiding screens first thing in the morning, limiting background noise to promote conversations, and avoiding screens in bedrooms and at meal times are all good ideas.
It’s recommended that parents sit down with their toddler and watch together – this can promote small discussions and shared interests. Making small steps to model the types of screen use behaviours parents want to see in their kids can go a long way – particularly for the early years.
Using screens responsibly
Many young people have come to the realization themselves that they don’t want to be glued to their phones, Ann Hui says.GETTY IMAGES
What have some parents done that has worked for them and their children?
Hui: One of the best pieces of advice I received when reporting this story was from a Toronto mom to a young toddler, Dana Infald. She’s a screen-free parent, and advised that parents break up their days into “chunks.” So instead of seeing it as a whole day to have to somehow fill for your child, scheduling the parts of days into two-hour increments. Two hours of outdoor time. Two hours of free play, etc. This can help with the sense of overwhelm from having to schedule an entire day.
I’ve started implementing this in my own household too, albeit in more limited way. On weeknights, we have designated “reading time” and “homework time” and “free play time” now. This has helped us to give some structure around our time – and given my daughter clearer expectations too around how we spend our time. So it’s cut down on her asking for screen time too.
It’s easy to control a two-year-old’s screen time but what about when they start getting older and asking why they don’t have phones like their friends?
Hui: In my reporting around screen time and teenagers (and especially around the use of social media), one thing that’s struck me over and over again is how many young people have come to the realization themselves that they don’t want to be glued to their phones.
Earlier this year, I spoke with a number of Gen Zs – young people who grew up on iPads, in the “Wild West” of screens, about how they grew up. Many of them talked about how they’ve decided all on their own to limit their own screen time.
I’m not saying this is representative of all young people, but I do think that it’s interesting that many of those who were exposed to this stuff from the earliest age are also among those to understand the risks first.

