![13th Mar: A Cinderella Story (2004), 1hr 35m [PG] – Streaming Again (5.95/10)](https://occ-0-8465-999.1.nflxso.net/dnm/api/v6/Qs00mKCpRvrkl3HZAN5KwEL1kpE/AAAABQWsApy8DgWnYStW4NnctKebFi-ShMunNfsySOGhcA4DNfkFPYVBdjfbPJkFtf83XcL7Gn7DThK4Qsr47V9qwh3T3_0n2OilxF3X.jpg?r=004 "13th Mar: A Cinderella Story (2004), 1hr 35m [PG] – Streaming Again (5.95/10)")
PLOT: After prison, a woman attempts to reconnect with her young daughter but faces resistance from everyone except a bar owner with ties to her child. As they grow closer, she must confront her past mistakes to build a hopeful future.
REVIEW: Colleen Hoover seems to be the new Nicolas Sparks in terms of romance books being adapted into film. I was never a Sparks guy, and I can definitely say I’m not a Hoover guy, as it’s quite frustrating that she keeps getting movies made. I didn’t enjoy It Ends With Us or Regretting You, but I could see the appeal to certain audiences. Reminders of Him is a new low, as it can’t even be saved by its two lead actors, who I tend to enjoy in all of their other roles. But they’re constantly dragged down by a story that feels like it was written by a robot.
Reminders of Him follows Maika Monroe’s Kenna as she’s released from prison and trying to restart her life and reconnect with the child she lost along the way. And what better time to have a meet-cute with her baby daddy’s best friend, Ledger (Withers), with whom she develops a love connection. There are times when it just feels like a mishmash of romance tropes and is absolutely suffocating with its stupidity. Every time a new element is introduced, it’s as insane as the last one and feels so over-the-top.
Usually, I talk about the performances first, but I feel like I need to mention the writing, as there’s just no actor on earth that could pull off what is on the page. Colleen Hoover seems adamant to create the most unrealistic characters/situations that her mind can conjure. The dialogue, which tries to tug at your heartstrings, results in so many unintentionally funny moments. They try to make the phrase “is that a frickin’ pigeon” into a thing. Even the title, Reminders of Him, feels so on the nose that it slaps you over the head with it repeatedly. Yes, we know, Kenna is reminded of him.
I’ve always really liked Maika Monroe, from It Follows to The Guest, but she feels miscast here. Her narration feels disjointed and doesn’t ever connect in any meaningful way. She has good chemistry with Tyriq Withers, who seems to be great in anything he does, but their romance feels forced. They feel drawn to each other, not because of circumstances that naturally bring them together, but simply because the writer says these two need to get together. It feels unnatural and makes the moments they do finally get together ring hollow.
There’s melodramatic, and then there’s whatever Reminders of Him tries to do. I’m not sure there’s a single moment that actually comes across as real outside of the ending. Otherwise, this just feels like a story that’s so disengaged from reality and is just trying to create some drama porn. There are awkward editing choices that had me laughing out loud. Which is good, because the only other bit of humor comes from a character with Down syndrome, who the writers decide to just say random things for bits of levity.
If there’s one element that stood out, it’s the cinematography, which showcases Wyoming and its beautiful landscapes. There’s a house at one point that has one of the best views you can imagine. It’s too bad we spend so much of the rest of the film in drab bars, backrooms, and rundown motels. And I’m not sure whose idea it was to denote the passage of time with different facial hair, but it resulted in some terrible looks.
Twenty minutes into Reminders of Him, and I knew I was in for trouble. I’ll always enjoy a thoughtful romance, but this is void of anything that could even be considered as such. Every major moment feels unearned, and its narrative structure destroys any forward momentum between the characters. The plot moves forward, not because the characters are able to prove themselves, but because the runtime is drawing to a close and they need to wrap things up.
Reminders of Him releases to theaters on March 13th, 2026.
