Close Menu
Canadian ReviewsCanadian Reviews
  • What’s On
  • Reviews
  • Digital World
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel
  • Trending
  • Web Stories
Trending Now

New GTA 6 Screenshots Show Off A Crucial Next-Gen Feature

There’s a free Christmas market and festive Santa Claus parade coming to Alberta

Get ready for a nationwide emergency alert test at 2:20PM ET today

Toronto just got snubbed on Air Canada’s New Restaurant list—only one lone restaurant made the cut, Canada Reviews

Future of AI in travel: The Intelligent Journey

Southwest’s New Deal With French bee Lets You Fly to Paris, Tahiti, and the Maldives on a Single (Affordable) Ticket

A City Winery music and dining venue coming to Toronto and it’s going to be huge, Canada Reviews

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Advertise
  • Contact us
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Vimeo
Canadian ReviewsCanadian Reviews
  • What’s On
  • Reviews
  • Digital World
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel
  • Trending
  • Web Stories
Newsletter
Canadian ReviewsCanadian Reviews
You are at:Home » Should Canada put more weight on language skills when selecting immigrants?
Lifestyle

Should Canada put more weight on language skills when selecting immigrants?

17 November 20267 Mins Read

The Canadian think tank, C.D. Howe Institute, is recommending advanced English and French language skills be given greater weight in the country’s immigration selection system after a new study found that university-educated immigrants perform only slightly better on literacy tests than Canadian-born high school graduates.

But while economists, language specialists and immigration professionals acknowledge the importance of language proficiency, they question whether giving it more importance would improve immigrants’ economic outcomes. They say that Canada’s Express Entry already heavily rewards language skills, and labour-market demand, professional requirements and the long-term value of education also influence earnings.

The study, released Oct. 27, found that university-educated immigrants scored an average of 273 on English and French literacy assessments, compared with 312 for Canadian-born university graduates and 268 for Canadian-born high-school graduates. However, the study draws on data covering immigrants admitted through different pathways — not specifically those selected through the Express Entry economic stream.

Parisa Mahboubi, the study’s author and a senior policy analyst at C.D. Howe Institute, recommends redistributing points within Express Entry to reward advanced language proficiency more heavily, rather than simply raising minimum requirements.

What the study does, and doesn’t, show

Mahboubi’s study draws on the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development’s (OECD) 2023 Survey of Adult Skills, which assesses literacy, numeracy and problem-solving abilities. She examined the literacy gap between immigrants and Canadian-born adults using a 2012 survey, allowing her to compare results over a decade.

Parisa Mahboubi, associate director of research, C.D. Howe Institute.

Her latest analysis found that approximately half of university-educated immigrants scored at Level 2 or below on the OECD’s five-level literacy scale, compared with about 15 per cent of Canadian-born university graduates. The overall literacy gap narrowed only slightly between the two surveys, and was not statistically significant, Mahboubi said.

But the OECD assessments only measure literacy in English or French, not an immigrant’s full range of professional abilities.

“What those tests show you really, is what people’s capabilities are in the language the test is written in,” said Tracey Derwing, professor emerita at the University of Alberta’s Teaching English as a Second Language program.

“You could have somebody who is really highly skilled in their own language, but that information isn’t going to come across if they don’t speak English or French to that level.”

Mahboubi acknowledges that language barriers may prevent immigrants from demonstrating their underlying abilities. Her study also cannot distinguish immigrants selected through Express Entry from those admitted through other pathways, including family sponsorship, refugee programs and economic immigration streams outside Express Entry.

Express Entry accounts for roughly one quarter of Canada’s annual permanent resident admissions, Mahboubi said. That means the study’s findings cannot establish whether immigrants selected through Express Entry have the same literacy gaps as the broader immigrant population.

“We shouldn’t look only at degrees when making immigration decisions,” she said.

How much should language count?

Language proficiency already carries considerable weight in Express Entry. 

Applicants without an accompanying spouse can earn up to 160 of the 500 core points for English and French proficiency, compared with 150 for education and 110 for age. Language skills can also earn additional points when combined with education or foreign work experience.

In a statement to New Canadian Media, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) said language proficiency attracts more points than any other factor. The department cited its own research showing that immigrants with stronger skills in the country’s official languages generally have better employment and earnings outcomes.

Arthur Sweetman, a McMaster University economics professor who specializes in immigration and labour markets, agreed that stronger language proficiency can improve economic outcomes, particularly for university-educated immigrants.

“Language skills mediate the return to education,” Sweetman said, adding that two immigrants with equivalent degrees may earn different returns on their qualifications depending on their English proficiency. 

“Language skills help unlock the value of education.”

But Sweetman questions whether stronger language requirements would be equally useful across occupations. 

“For people with a university education, yes. For people in skilled trades, it’s not clear that it matters as much.”

Immigration lawyer Andrew Carvajal agrees that language proficiency is a strong predictor of professional success, but he cautions that giving it even more weight could disadvantage experienced tradespeople.

“Some very accomplished candidates would score lower than candidates with less experience but stronger test results,” Carvajal said.

But Mahboubi opposes tailoring language requirements to individual professions.

“I don’t think language requirements should be linked to the particular jobs individuals are going to hold,” she said.

Why timing and labour-market demand matter

Feng Hou, a senior researcher at Statistics Canada, said language proficiency is among the strongest predictors of immigrants’ employment and earnings, but that its relative importance changes over time.

“For initial earnings, or earnings during the first five years, Canadian work experience, particularly the quality of that experience, is one of the most important factors,” he said.

Language proficiency also matters considerably in the early years, while education and age at arrival become increasingly important predictors of earnings over the longer term, Hou said.

“In the first few years after arrival, education may not make a huge difference to earnings. But over 10 or 20 years, it becomes a strong predictor.”

That distinction complicates the question of redistributing immigration points if doing so reduces the weight given to qualifications associated with long-term economic success.

Hou said labour-market demand can substantially change an immigrant’s prospects.

For instance, during Canada’s technology boom in the late 1990s, immigrant IT workers earned approximately the same salary as Canadian-born workers. Following the downturn, their earnings fell substantially behind.

More recently, his research found that immigrant data scientists earned roughly as much as their Canadian-born counterparts in 2021, when demand for their skills was strong.

“When demand is strong, immigrant status doesn’t matter nearly as much.” 

Language isn’t the only barrier

Even immigrants with excellent English or French skills can struggle to find work matching their qualifications, said Oumar Dicko, director of public and francophone affairs at World Education Services.

“There are immigrants who have excellent language skills. They also have the education, experience and skills required, but they’re still struggling to find jobs commensurate with those qualifications,” he said.

Dicko pointed to Canada’s fragmented credential-recognition system, where provincial regulations and professional licensing requirements vary.

“Attracting highly skilled immigrants is only one part of the story,” he said, adding that Canada must also create conditions that allow newcomers to succeed after arrival.

Derwing, the University of Alberta professor, cautioned that Canada competes with countries such as Australia, Britain and the United States for highly skilled immigrants who already speak English or French.

“I feel that if we can attract highly skilled people who have the skills necessary for the jobs available here, it’s worth the investment to help them with language when they arrive,” she said.

Yet Ottawa has been scaling back its support for language skills. 

IRCC moved to phase out federally funded advanced English and French language classes by September 2026, prioritizing foundational language instruction instead.

Mahboubi believes that stronger language skills at selection, as well as continued settlement support, are necessary. Encouraging prospective Express Entry applicants to improve their English or French before arriving could free resources for refugees, family-sponsored immigrants and others who need more assistance after arrival, she said.

“I believe we need both strategies. Stronger language proficiency through immigration selection and better post-arrival support for immigrants who need it.”

 

 

 

Copyright 2026, New Canadian Media. All rights reserved.

Mubin S. Khan, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter, New Canadian Media.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Reddit WhatsApp Telegram Email

Related Articles

New GTA 6 Screenshots Show Off A Crucial Next-Gen Feature

Lifestyle 17 November 2026

Southwest’s New Deal With French bee Lets You Fly to Paris, Tahiti, and the Maldives on a Single (Affordable) Ticket

Lifestyle 17 November 2026

This Toronto hotel has group dinners, birthday cake and later night parties all under one roof, Life in canada

Lifestyle 17 November 2026

Should I stay or should I sell? A guide to housing regret | Canada Voices

Lifestyle 17 November 2026

17th Nov: See You on Venus (2023), 1hr 35m [TV-PG] – Streaming Again (6.05/10)

Lifestyle 17 November 2026

The Home Depot names new CEO following Ted Decker stepping down

Lifestyle 17 November 2026
Top Articles
Why Should a Couple in Love Visit an Escape Room?

Why Should a Couple in Love Visit an Escape Room?

30 September 2025165 Views
The Mother May I Story – Chickpea Edition

The Mother May I Story – Chickpea Edition

18 May 2024106 Views
How to Keep Your Business Finances Organized All Year Round

How to Keep Your Business Finances Organized All Year Round

3 October 202598 Views
LearnToTrade: A Comprehensive Look at the Controversial Trading School

LearnToTrade: A Comprehensive Look at the Controversial Trading School

28 April 202484 Views
Demo
Don't Miss
Lifestyle 17 November 2026

Southwest’s New Deal With French bee Lets You Fly to Paris, Tahiti, and the Maldives on a Single (Affordable) Ticket

Budget-conscious travelers looking to cross bucket-list international destinations off their list just got a major…

A City Winery music and dining venue coming to Toronto and it’s going to be huge, Canada Reviews

This Toronto hotel has group dinners, birthday cake and later night parties all under one roof, Life in canada

Should I stay or should I sell? A guide to housing regret | Canada Voices

About Us
About Us

Canadian Reviews is your one-stop website for the latest Canadian trends and things to do, follow us now to get the news that matters to you.

Facebook X (Twitter) Pinterest YouTube WhatsApp
Our Picks

New GTA 6 Screenshots Show Off A Crucial Next-Gen Feature

There’s a free Christmas market and festive Santa Claus parade coming to Alberta

Get ready for a nationwide emergency alert test at 2:20PM ET today

Most Popular
Why You Should Consider Investing with IC Markets

Why You Should Consider Investing with IC Markets

28 April 202435 Views
OANDA Review – Low costs and no deposit requirements

OANDA Review – Low costs and no deposit requirements

28 April 2024370 Views
LearnToTrade: A Comprehensive Look at the Controversial Trading School

LearnToTrade: A Comprehensive Look at the Controversial Trading School

28 April 202484 Views
© 2026 ThemeSphere. Designed by ThemeSphere.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Advertise
  • Contact us

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.