Toronto diners used to think of Niagara purely as wine-tour territory — a place for white tablecloths among the vines, followed by a quiet drive back to the city. Over the past few years, chef Zach Smith has quietly dismantled that reputation. Since leaving his post at Toronto’s Bar Raval in 2020 (where he has since returned as a co-owner, alongside opening the Spanish steakhouse Casa Rubia), Smith has turned downtown St. Catharines into a serious culinary detour.
First came Fat Rabbit, a whole-animal butcher shop and restaurant that earned a Michelin Guide recommendation. Then came Bar Les Incompétents, a moody, French-ish spot down the block that recently picked up a Michelin Bib Gourmand and landed on Air Canada’s Best New Restaurants list — a ranking that included only a single Toronto restaurant this year.
Smith is now going in the opposite direction of tasting menus and white tablecloths. On Nov. 20, he opens Sunset Steak and Cheese at 180 St. Paul Street, taking over the historic, 70-year-old Sunset Restaurant. Rather than gutting the room, Smith and designer Keri Maclellan are keeping the original booths and the vintage sign tuning up only the lighting and sound.

The menu at Sunset Steak is a love letter to Philadelphia’s sandwich counters Thinly sliced beef — sourced separately from Fat Rabbit’s whole-animal program to keep prices accessible — hits the flat top with onions before getting tucked into soft, structured rolls. Options range from a classic Philly build to The Big Coop, made with Cooper Sharp, and The Wizzard, slicked with Cheez Whiz. Rounding out the counter are roast pork and rapini sandwiches, Italian subs, Chicago dogs, chili-cheese fries and milkshakes.
Behind the bar, St. Catharines native Juliana Wolkowski of Lowboy Studios has put together a drinks list of cold beer, early-2000s shooters and supper-club cocktails with a tropical streak. The idea, Smith says, is to build a room where students, families, and off-duty line cooks can all eat at the same time.

