A Tedious Brief Review of “Goodnight Desdemona, Good Morning, Juliet,” very tragical mirth
When Ann-Marie MacDonald set to write
This bardic romp in 1988
She posited that some of Shakespeare’s works
Were tragedies by simple twist of fate.
For lack of fools, the characters from plays
Othello, Romeo and Juliet
Were doomed to die — no jester stays the hand
Of miscommunication-prompted death.
From Nightwood 40 years ago to now
Revived in style at the Bluma Appel
MacDonald’s work is solid, and indeed
It still casts an Elizabethan spell.
Alisa Palmer skilfully directs
A silly farce with pacing quick and light —
Some social commentary floats on top,
But mostly it’s a frothy, foamy night.
Canadian Stage returns it to the boards
With Ms. MacDonald as the lead again.
She’s Constance Ledbelly, the put-upon
Untenured prof who writes with a quill pen.
Her theories on how Shakespeare stole these plots
Compare with how her own hard work is thieved:
Prof. Night, her crush and academic foil,
Through woman’s toil a man’s career achieved.
The play makes pointed updates for the time —
Cellphones, hashtags, and woke diversity;
They’re fun, but stick out from the otherwise
Preserved-in-amber university.
The sexist work environment would still
Cut sharp; the “Elbows Up” does not decrease
Our knowledge that this script is pre-AI.
It’s fine to stay a loving period piece.
As Constance tumbles through a garbage can
And lands in works she’d cover in her class,
These updates are another way the show
Puts itself through a sort of looking glass.
But it’s a glancing look and not a dive
That magnifies the mustiness instead;
It’s when it tries to fix the tragedy
That this erstwhile production steams ahead.
When Constance gets transported to the plays
As Shakespeare’s Mary Sue, the perfect Fool,
Her theory’s tested and her mettle’s plucked
As both works’ heroines find her nerd self cool.
MacDonald’s charming, flustered little sprite
Who holds desire and rage at an arm’s length
Is overwhelmed but perseveres with grit —
Her genre knowledge proves to be her strength.
Othello’s land is first; our mousy lead
Meets Desdemona (Jessica B. Hill,
Whose Emilia at Stratford was a force,
Imbues this role with equal strength of will).
Hill’s Desdemona is a warrior queen
Imposing with a sword as Constance quails;
Praneet Akilla’s Iago snivels well
When his attempt at smothering her fails.
If Desdemona’s always set to kill
Then Juliet’s as eager yet to die:
Caroline Toal looks for an exit ramp
As wedding night desire becomes a lie.
And Romeo (Akilla too) looks bleak:
In morning light, his eyes stray to new girls,
Their love had a quick expiration date
No matter how the tale this time unfurls.
Toal’s wide-eyed admiration and her angst
Befit teenage impulsiveness and spunk
(Like Viola, her Dream in High Park role,
But here her love life’s, not her sailboat’s, sunk)
She chases Constance; Romeo does too,
A sex farce that puts gender in the fray
It’s all good fun that makes the evening bright
With joy, and more than just a little gay.
Carolyn Taylor scores the greatest hits
As Night, Othello, Tybalt, and the Nurse
She struts, conceited, master of the house
A figure condescending in blank verse.
She’s dressed in Judith Bowden’s neon garb;
Her Nurse is draped in volumes of soft gauze.
The tights and pronounced codpieces delight
With racing stripes accenting any flaws.
The heightened clothes and affect in this world,
A contrast with our Constance and her tweed
Denotes this as escapist fantasy,
Where things work out and all our pains recede.
But even fancy’s rooted in our cares,
Reflecting the anxieties of life,
Constance, who finds frustration with the pen,
Can strike misogyny with brandished knife.
The set (also by Bowden) tow’rs aloft
Resembling a file cabinet from Hell
Stripped down to frames when in the Shakespeare worlds
It shows the construct ‘neath the stories well.
Pacing increases as the iambs race;
The first act could be tighter, but the next
Feels like inspired lunacy as we
Increasingly get caught inside the text.
So Ann-Marie MacDonald’s show returns
With love, a fond remembrance that still zings
Its pleasant two hours’ traffic rouses, while
Satiric arrows with sharp wit it slings.
And though the updates aren’t of any need,
Canadian Stage has little to regret;
It’s a good night for Desdemona, and
No mourning now for feisty Juliet.
Goodnight Desdemona (Good Morning Juliet) runs at the Bluma Appel Theatre until November 22. More information is available here.
Intermission reviews are independent and unrelated to Intermission’s partnered content. Learn more about Intermission’s partnership model here.

