The Museum of Toronto will blaze a trail, building on civic pride and amping it up, Alex Bozikovic writes.EDUARDO LIMA/The Globe and Mail
At Yonge and Queen Streets, a former bank is about to become something Toronto has awaited for more than half a century: a comprehensive museum of its history. The Museum of Toronto recently announced it will open a permanent location at 2 Queen St. East next spring.
Funded by a $35-million donation from founders Diane Blake and Stephen Smith, the new space is a turning point for Toronto. But Museum of Toronto is a private institution, and city government is nursing its own plans for a civic museum at Old City Hall just a few minutes away. Is there room for two city museums in this town?
The MoT has planted its flag at an unusual spot, among the theatre crowds opposite the Eaton Centre. “It’s where civic life and commercial life kind of come together,” museum director Heidi Reitmaier explained recently. “People can learn a bit about the history of the city, and find pride and joy in the place they live.”
So how will it tell the story of Toronto? The institution started out in 2014 as Myseum of Toronto. In recent years, it has shown engaging physical exhibitions on themes such as children’s TV, nature in the city and the cultural history of basketball.
Museum of Toronto director Heidi Reitmaier, left, and architect Meg Graham in front of the museum, on Nov. 11. Ms. Reitmaier suggests her organization will draw on the collections of other local institutions. That’s a tricky balancing act, Bozikovic writes.EDUARDO LIMA/The Globe and Mail
The exhibitions, designed by Elsonstudio, will include a permanent show, called This Toronto of Ours: A City in Six Parts. A temporary exhibition space, which will rotate annually, launches with Lights, Camera, T.O.: Toronto on Film.
A civic museum is a basic piece of public infrastructure. Any city worth its salt has one. Toronto does not, though the idea has been under discussion since the 1960s, and there’s an obvious venue at Old City Hall. That massive 1899 building at Queen and Bay served as a courthouse from 1965 until last year. Now it’s empty, and the city is figuring out how to use it; the plans include a museum in some form. But details remain hazy and the funding hazier.
Such vagueness prompted Ms. Blake and Mr. Smith to found their organization in 2014. “The city wasn’t doing anything, I think, and they’re not doing anything,” Mr. Smith says bluntly of the city’s museum plans. Mr. Smith is the billionaire co-founder of mortgage lender First National Financial, and the couple are serious philanthropists with an interest in history; their projects include Historica Canada.
In 2014, they launched Myseum of Toronto as a “museum without walls.” Initially led by curator Karen Carter, this was an insurgency into the world of history museums. In 2021, they recruited Ms. Reitmaier, who had served brief stints as deputy director at the Art Gallery of Ontario and director and chief executive officer at the Museum of Contemporary Art. The MoT moved into a modest space at 401 Richmond.
Toronto’s Old City Hall could soon be a home for its civic treasures. It can be more than that
This is an example of the city’s government being outpaced by private actors. But everyone involved plays down the idea of competition; instead, the proponents argue the two institutions can co-exist and complement each other, with the city’s collection of largely older art and artifacts on one hand, and MoT’s attention to the vibes of post-1950 Toronto.
Karen Carter, who is now the City of Toronto’s director of museum and heritage services, says there is “absolutely” room for both museums. “I’m excited to see this new financial commitment from Diane and Stephen,” she says. “I’m looking forward to collaborating with the team wherever possible and sharing the city’s collection for exhibition.”
Which raises a crucial detail about the Museum of Toronto’s future. It does not collect, and so it will rely heavily on borrowing from the city’s hoard of 1.3 million objects. Yet Canadian institutions generally cannot loan artifacts on a long-term basis, so a permanent exhibition will be challenging. Ms. Reitmaier suggests her organization will also draw on the collections of other local institutions. That’s a tricky balancing act.
Meanwhile, a block away, Old City Hall needs new vision. The right approach to that building will contain a mix of culture, commerce and civic institutions, as I argued last year. The city is quietly mulling a mixed-use strategy.
Alex Bozikovic: How Old City Hall can be Toronto’s new heart
The Museum of Toronto could be part of that future. Ms. Carter says she in close touch with the institution, and Ms. Blake and Mr. Smith don’t rule out a collaboration. “We are on board with an incremental approach to Old City Hall,” Ms. Blake says, “and we think we could be one of the increments. But that doesn’t mean we have to slow down and wait.”
That is fair. With luck, Toronto’s leaders will follow Ms. Blake and Mr. Smith’s lead and adopt their sense of urgency. The city should push a vision of a civic museum that is plausible in the short term and works with the Old City Hall building, rather than one that works against it with a huge, costly renovation, as previous city plans have suggested.
Meanwhile, MoT will blaze a trail, building on civic pride and amping it up. “There is a humility to the way we present ourselves here,” Ms. Reitmaier says. “I’ve worked in Chicago and London, and those cities own their history. There’s a volume to the way they speak, and Toronto doesn’t do that. One of the joys of this job has been that we can increase the volume a bit.”

