Close Menu
Canadian ReviewsCanadian Reviews
  • What’s On
  • Reviews
  • Digital World
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel
  • Trending
  • Web Stories
Trending Now

How did Grand Theft Auto VI create its lifelike characters? Ask these theatre actors | Canada Voices

“Rope” Hides a Body Handsomely in a Killer Apartment – front mezz junkies, Theater News

Mamdani announces plans to close Rikers Island by 2032

The average Quebec salary is under $70K a year — Here’s how every other province stacks up

CoStar, Tourism Economics Raise U.S. Hotel Growth Forecast :: Hospitality Trends

Cross 2′ Sets December 2026 Netflix Release After Delay

Did an Online Long COVID Clinic’s Model Spur Changes to MSP Billing?

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Advertise
  • Contact us
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Vimeo
Canadian ReviewsCanadian Reviews
  • What’s On
  • Reviews
  • Digital World
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel
  • Trending
  • Web Stories
Newsletter
Canadian ReviewsCanadian Reviews
You are at:Home » “Rope” Hides a Body Handsomely in a Killer Apartment – front mezz junkies, Theater News
Reviews

“Rope” Hides a Body Handsomely in a Killer Apartment – front mezz junkies, Theater News

20 November 20269 Mins Read
Cameron Monaghan and Corey Fogelmanis in The New Group’s Rope at the Theatre at St. Clement’s. Photo by Monique Carboni.

An Off-Broadway Theatre Review: The New Group’s audacious production explores the dangerous entanglement of desire, power, shame, and the intoxicating pleasure of control.

By Ross

Two young men in white boxer shorts, one wearing a T-shirt, the other looking particularly comfortable in his own skin, take their positions at the far wall of the stage. Their differences in temperament and confidence are already apparent in the way they sit, gazing out into the distance, even before either has said a word. Then they move together with practised efficiency, arranging the desk and furniture, setting out the serving bar and Christmas treats, and carefully stepping around the rolled-up carpet resting at the foot of the grand piano. As the apartment takes shape, Derek McLane‘s handsome set design beautifully and engagingly reveals this elegantly appointed Sutton Place living room where a crime has been committed, complete with festive preparations and one very inconveniently heavy piece of furniture at its centre. The room comes together splendidly, and so does the deceptive, uneasy world of Rope.

It’s the most captivating beginning, with the music accompanying the set-up delivering a deliciously Hitchcockian flavour, with Leah Gelpe‘s sound design helping to establish the atmosphere as Garrett and Nate put the finishing touches on their carefully constructed crime scene. The Christmas tree is in place, the drinks are ready, and the final piece of the puzzle sits taking its central role quite heavily. And I suspect we all know why. Adapted by Gordon Greenberg from Patrick Hamilton’s 1929 play and directed with care and consideration by Scott Elliott, this New Group production at the Theatre at St. Clement’s announces its intentions with considerable style, giving the familiar murder premise an explicitly queer identity from the get-go, with a distinctly unsettling sense of intimacy woven through it.

James Waterston, Elizabeth Gillies, Jason Butler Harner, Corey Fogelmanis (seated), Graham Phillips, and Cameron Monaghan (standing) in The New Group’s Rope at the Theatre at St. Clement’s. Photo by Monique Carboni.

“Are you okay, Nate?” Garrett asks, with a forced tenderness that carries its own agenda. Nate needs this man’s confident reassurance, his approval. “You wanted this,” he tells him, followed by the promise that “No one will ever know.” Cameron Monaghan (“Shameless“) settles comfortably into Garrett’s position of power, giving him the assured confidence of a man who already knows how the evening will unfold, and whose appeal to Nate is all too easy to understand. That influence is so complete that Nate even allows Garrett to take charge of his inhaler, making it crystal clear who controls access to something he may desperately need. It is a chilling little demonstration of control, and Corey Fogelmanis (“My Life with the Walter Boys“) makes Nate’s willingness to surrender to it both fascinating and uncomfortable to watch. He captures Nate’s nervous energy with an almost painful physical alertness. He is visibly struggling to contain himself, and when the phone rings and he answers it, the fragility of their arrangement becomes immediately apparent. Garrett may have orchestrated the murder, but Nate is the person he will have to manage throughout the evening, with sex, dependence, and intellectual superiority all tangled up in their dangerous relationship. And we lean in, sensing that the fragile arrangement between them is beginning to give way.

Greenberg (Dracula, A Comedy of Terrors) moves the action of Rope to 1957 Manhattan and brings the relationship between the two killers out of the coded shadows that surrounded the story in its earlier incarnations. The adaptation wisely draws on the notorious 1924 Leopold and Loeb murder case, giving Garrett and Nate Jewish identities and exploring the pressures of living as gay men in a society determined to keep both parts of themselves hidden. That context adds a troubling psychological dimension to their shared fantasy of superiority and control. Jeff Croiter‘s lighting gives the room its shifting pockets of intimacy and suspicion, subtly changing the atmosphere as the guests settle in and the carefully maintained social performance begins to fray. Their Princeton professor, Rupert Cadell, becomes another important part of this complicated thesis on control, seduction, and the dangerous consequences of intellectual games. Played with a wonderfully theatrical mixture of charm and intellectual mischief by Jason Butler Harner (Broadway’s The Crucible), Rupert has helped shape the young men’s ideas about bravery, danger, and the supposed freedom that comes from rejecting conventional morality. He also has a sordid history with Garrett, adding another layer of sexual tension and manipulation to the gathering. The professor’s own secrets make his arrival particularly charged. He lets himself in with his own key, seemingly convinced that he has the upper hand in the room, before gradually recognizing the consequences of the ideas he once tossed around so casually.

Elizabeth Gillies and Graham Phillips in The New Group’s Rope at the Theatre at St. Clement’s. Photo by Monique Carboni.

The dinner party itself gives the ensemble plenty of room to imbibe, parley, and play, and the cast makes excellent use of the sharp banter and carefully observed social behaviour. Elizabeth Gillies (Off-Broadway’s Little Shop of Horrors) expertly brings a welcome perceptiveness to the glamorous Leila, whose sharp observations and instincts allow her to detect the discomfort bubbling beneath the party’s polished surface. Catherine Zuber‘s period costumes give Gillies an especially cultivated presence, helping establish the social polish and carefully maintained appearances that define this gathering. Graham Phillips (Broadway’s 13: The Musical) plays the likeable, empty-headed Richard with an easygoing obliviousness that makes him a useful embodiment of the privileged Princeton world Garrett and Nate both resent and imitate. James Waterston (Broadway’s Enemy of the People) brings warmth and genuine paternal concern to Judge Kentley, whose trust in the young hosts makes his growing unease particularly uncomfortable to watch. As the guests drink, smoke, sing, and attempt to make sense of an oddly timed post-Christmas gathering, Nate remains on edge, practically vibrating with anxiety. Garrett, meanwhile, seems to relish his position as host and ringmaster, controlling the room with a confidence that is increasingly difficult to ignore.

The construction of the evening is one of Greenberg’s more intriguing choices, though it occasionally loosens the carefully wound tension of the suspense. As characters take their places, they periodically step into pools of light to address us directly, offering glimpses into their personas. These fourth-wall-breaking addresses provide an effective way of establishing the temperature of the room, exposing the private tensions and unspoken resentments each character brings into the gathering. I appreciated the additional insight into these characters, particularly Rupert and Garrett, but the pauses repeatedly draw the evening away from the mounting unease of the unfolding action. The murder and its aftermath are built around a wonderfully simple theatrical premise, with the guests gathering around a trunk containing the body of a young man whose absence should surely register, especially by his own father. The tension should be almost unbearable as the party continues, conversations drift, and the possibility of discovery hangs over every exchange. The adaptation has plenty to say about the people in the room, but its appetite for explaining their histories repeatedly interrupts the delicious tension of watching Garrett and Nate maintain their carefully constructed charade.

The queer reimagining gives Rope a particular cultural and emotional charge, deepening the psychological tensions simmering beneath the party’s carefully maintained veneer of carefree sociability. Garrett and Nate are products of a world that offers them few acceptable ways to understand their desires, and each responds to the resulting shame and resentment in his own way. Garrett’s hunger for power and domination sits uneasily alongside Nate’s need for love, security, and companionship, the disparity between them giving their relationship its particularly troubling charge. For Garrett, the murder becomes an appalling expression of the superiority he imagines himself to possess, a way of orchestrating a world that has him at the top of the food chain.

Jason Butler Harner and Cameron Monaghan in The New Group’s Rope at the Theatre at St. Clement’s. Photo by Monique Carboni.

Rupert’s presence both elevates and complicates that fantasy, bringing his own history of concealment and intellectual posturing into the room. There is plenty of material here about the damage done by social repression, and the production is at its most compelling when those pressures emerge through the characters’ behaviour. Monaghan and Fogelmanis give the central relationship a compelling clarity, with Garrett’s calculated ease playing against Nate’s increasingly desperate need for approval. Harner adds another fascinating dimension to that triangle, and his scenes with Monaghan carry the unmistakable charge of a shared sexual history, one that Garrett seems particularly adept at using to his advantage. The result is a stylish, often captivating evening, even when the adaptation’s structural choices leave a few stubborn creases in the carefully rolled-out carpet.

Greenberg has given Rope a magnificent, sexy new life, with killer instincts and a wonderfully assured visual sense. He has opened up the queer and Jewish dimensions of these characters with considerable boldness, exploring territory Hitchcock could only hint at in 1948. The decision to bring their desires and insecurities into the foreground gives the familiar premise a fresh psychological life. Yet the trunk remains the great unspoken presence in the room, the centrepiece of Garrett’s elaborate game of deception. He has invited these people into Nate’s home as if they are a well-established ‘couple’, served them drinks, entertained them, and drawn them into a performance in which he alone knows the truth, a sly reflection of the closeted lives gay men were forced to lead at that time. There is a particularly chilling pleasure in watching him toy with this gathering of social and intellectual elites, so confident in his ability to manipulate their perceptions, maintain his superiority, and walk away with everything he wants. All the Christmas cheer, the handsome apartment, the elegant clothes, and the sparkling conversation become part of the deception. Garrett may believe he gets to say what is real, and the Rope itself seems to offer little threat to his composure as he produces it and talks his way around its presence on the couch. The body in that trunk is another matter. Some secrets, however beautifully the room is arranged, cannot be hidden away forever.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Reddit WhatsApp Telegram Email

Related Articles

REVIEW: Goodnight Desdemona (Good Morning Juliet) — an appraisal in verse, Theater News

Reviews 20 November 2026

A week of choices on Edmonton stages. Don’t be staying home., Theater News

Reviews 19 November 2026

REVIEW: What counts as indie, anyway? A look at Radiant Vermin, How to Defend Yourself, and Pippin

Reviews 19 November 2026

“Macbeth” Has Entered the Chat, and the Witches Are Coming in Strong – front mezz junkies, Theater News

Reviews 19 November 2026

REVIEW: Coal Mine’s American Buffalo humanizes its prickly central characters — for better or worse, Theater News

Reviews 18 November 2026

“How to Defend Yourself” and the Difference Between a Surprise and Assault – front mezz junkies, Theater News

Reviews 18 November 2026
Top Articles
Why Should a Couple in Love Visit an Escape Room?

Why Should a Couple in Love Visit an Escape Room?

30 September 2025168 Views
The Mother May I Story – Chickpea Edition

The Mother May I Story – Chickpea Edition

18 May 2024107 Views
How to Keep Your Business Finances Organized All Year Round

How to Keep Your Business Finances Organized All Year Round

3 October 202598 Views
LearnToTrade: A Comprehensive Look at the Controversial Trading School

LearnToTrade: A Comprehensive Look at the Controversial Trading School

28 April 202486 Views
Demo
Don't Miss
What's On 20 November 2026

Cross 2′ Sets December 2026 Netflix Release After Delay

Picture: Mission: Cross 2 – Netflix Mission: Cross will return with a sequel on Netflix…

Did an Online Long COVID Clinic’s Model Spur Changes to MSP Billing?

UN court cites military Facebook posts while finding Myanmar guilty of genocide

Charming Ontario town hosts one of Canada’s oldest Christmas light festival — and it’s free, Canada Reviews

About Us
About Us

Canadian Reviews is your one-stop website for the latest Canadian trends and things to do, follow us now to get the news that matters to you.

Facebook X (Twitter) Pinterest YouTube WhatsApp
Our Picks

How did Grand Theft Auto VI create its lifelike characters? Ask these theatre actors | Canada Voices

“Rope” Hides a Body Handsomely in a Killer Apartment – front mezz junkies, Theater News

Mamdani announces plans to close Rikers Island by 2032

Most Popular
Why You Should Consider Investing with IC Markets

Why You Should Consider Investing with IC Markets

28 April 202436 Views
OANDA Review – Low costs and no deposit requirements

OANDA Review – Low costs and no deposit requirements

28 April 2024371 Views
LearnToTrade: A Comprehensive Look at the Controversial Trading School

LearnToTrade: A Comprehensive Look at the Controversial Trading School

28 April 202486 Views
© 2026 ThemeSphere. Designed by ThemeSphere.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Advertise
  • Contact us

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.