Unveiling the Reasons Why 80% of Americans Are Skeptical About AI

Widespread Distrust of AI Among Americans

A recent survey of 1,200 U.S. adults commissioned by WordPress VIP found that 86% of respondents do not fully trust information provided by artificial intelligence. The lack of transparency in AI-generated answers is a significant factor, with 42% of participants stating they are especially skeptical when AI responses do not clearly cite their sources. This distrust is more pronounced than skepticism toward other confusing or opaque information, such as medical bills (18%), legal documents (17%), or airline fees (10%).

The study indicates that Americans are not only wary of AI’s reliability but also take extra steps to independently verify information. The preference for original sources underscores a broader concern about the credibility of digital content.

Concerns Over Control and Accessibility of Online Information

The survey also revealed that 75% of Americans are worried that a small number of companies control much of the information available online. A large majority (81%) believe it is important for online information to remain openly accessible, rather than being restricted behind paywalls or dominated by large organizations.

These concerns reflect apprehension about the concentration of power in the digital information landscape and the potential for limited access or biased content.

Preference for Human Interaction Over AI

When engaging with businesses online, 75% of respondents said they find human representatives more helpful than AI, which only 15% preferred. More than half (56%) of those surveyed feel confident in their ability to distinguish AI from human interactions in online chats.

When asked which businesses use AI effectively in their brand messaging, 61% could not identify any, and 16% stated they do not believe any business uses AI well. Only about one in four could name a company at all, suggesting that AI’s role in brand communication remains unclear or unconvincing for many consumers.

Perceptions of a Less Human Internet

Three out of four Americans believe the internet today feels less human than it did a decade ago. On average, respondents estimate that 55% of their online interactions involve AI, and a similar proportion (54%) think their interactions on business websites are with AI rather than people.

Almost all respondents (92%) reported encountering AI or bots on social media, with 63% saying it happens frequently. The average person begins to feel fatigued by bot-generated content after just 40 minutes online.

Implications for Businesses and Marketers

The study also surveyed 800 U.S. marketing executives and digital experience experts. Among them, 74% said making their website content discoverable and clearly attributed in AI search and answer engines is a significant priority. Additionally, 91% believe it is important for their content to adopt a more human tone.

Misinformation from AI-generated responses is a concern for 39% of marketing professionals, who say it keeps them “up at night.” Furthermore, 69% believe that if their website content is not structured for public access, it will become invisible to AI search and answer engines.

Industry Perspectives on Trust and Visibility

Industry leaders emphasize the need for transparency and trust in digital experiences. They argue that visibility alone is insufficient if users cannot verify the source or connect information to a trusted brand. The findings suggest that companies must balance accessibility for both AI systems and human users, ensuring clarity and authenticity to maintain trust.

As AI continues to shape the digital landscape, both consumers and businesses are navigating new challenges related to trust, transparency, and control of information online.